Comparison · Paid Advertising
HomeAdvisor vs Angi: the same company, so here’s the real choice
If you’re weighing HomeAdvisor against Angi for your business, you’re comparing one company with itself. The choice that’s left is how you buy from Angi, and whether buying shared requests beats owning the demand yourself.
The verdict
Is HomeAdvisor the same company as Angi?
Yes. HomeAdvisor’s side for pros now runs as Angi Leads, and HomeAdvisor’s own pro site says so: “HomeAdvisor Pro is now Angi Leads” (HomeAdvisor pro site, checked November 11, 2026).
So the real choice on Angi today is between two ways to pay. Pay per lead on a monthly budget suits a newer or one-truck business filling a calendar, because you can turn it up, down or off. The Angi subscription only makes sense for a company that already knows how many Angi jobs it books each month and wants a discount for committing to a term.
What happened to HomeAdvisor
Both brands now belong to Angi Inc. In March 2021 ANGI Homeservices renamed itself Angi Inc. and the Angie’s List brand became Angi (Angi Inc. press release, 2021). That year’s annual report put the pro products under one roof: “Angi Ads operates under the Angi brand … Angi Leads operates primarily under the HomeAdvisor, powered by Angi brand” (Angi Inc. 2021 annual report).
HomeAdvisor still exists as a homeowner-facing brand. Angi Inc. still runs Angi, Angie’s List, HomeAdvisor and Handy as separate brands (Angi Inc. 2025 annual report), so a homeowner can still request a pro on a HomeAdvisor page and the request lands in the same Angi marketplace.
The bigger change came in 2025. Angi stopped selling Angi Ads, the old Angie’s List advertising product, in March 2025 (Angi Q1 2025 earnings release, 2025) and retired it in the fourth quarter of 2025, moving those pros onto a subscription for leads (Angi Inc. 2025 annual report). If a post tells you to choose between Angi Leads and Angi Ads, it’s describing a choice you can no longer make.
HomeAdvisor also has a history with the FTC: a complaint in March 2022 and a final order in April 2023 requiring it to pay up to $7.2 million in redress (FTC, 2023). We cover that order and the rest of the background in our breakdown of Angi, Thumbtack and owning your own demand.
Pay per lead vs the Angi subscription
Angi now sells pros two things: “full-priced leads within a monthly budget” and “access to discounted leads in a subscription package” (Angi Inc. 2025 annual report). Both draw from the same requests. The difference is who controls the spend and what you’re locked into.
| Pay per lead (Angi Leads) | Angi subscription | Your own website and Google profile | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you pay | A fee for each lead, billed weekly against a monthly budget you set. Angi doesn’t publish prices and says the fee depends on the task, the homeowner’s location and demand for the work. | You prepay for leads at a discount and are charged monthly. Opportunities you accept by hand are still billed at full price. | Ad spend on Google and Meta ads, plus SEO and website work. Nothing per request. |
| Is the request shared | Yes, with “no more than five pros.” Since January 2025 the homeowner picks which pros get their contact details, though Angi has said it may sell other leads as a separate product. | Same marketplace, same limit of five pros per request. | No. The homeowner found you and contacted you. |
| Contract terms | No fixed term found. You cancel through Angi Customer Care. | An “automatically renewing, fixed term commitment,” usually described as annual. An early termination fee may apply, and renewal can cost up to 10% more. | Whatever you agree with whoever does the work. Our engagements are month to month. |
| Who controls the budget | You. Change it in the app, pause leads for up to two weeks yourself, limit leads to business hours. | Mostly the contract. Annual subscribers call support to change the budget, and pausing leads doesn’t pause the contract. | You. Raise, cut or stop ad spend any day. |
| Bad leads | Request a credit for invalid leads less than 45 days old. | No lead credits on an annual subscription. | A bad inquiry costs the ad click that brought it in, with no lead fee on top. |
| What you can track | Lead status (some set when the homeowner says they hired you), billing statements and lead ratings. Return on spend is a manual calculation. | Same as pay per lead. | Calls, forms and bookings by source. Booked jobs and revenue too, where your job software allows it. |
The Angi columns come from Angi’s help center (checked November 11, 2026) and the Angi Pro Agreement, last updated October 6, 2026 (Angi Pro Agreement, checked November 11, 2026). Two lines from that agreement matter most for the subscription: getting fewer leads than Angi’s guidance suggested doesn’t excuse you from any fees or from the early termination fee, and prepaid fees aren’t refunded.
On both options you pay for a lead whether or not you win the job. The agreement says it plainly: “You will pay for the leads you receive, even if you do not win the job. Leads are not guaranteed jobs” (Angi Pro Agreement, checked November 11, 2026).
What a booked job costs on each
What you pay per booked job depends on how many shared requests you win. On the subscription you also pay the same whether the requests come or not.
The table walks one hypothetical business through a normal month and a slow month on each option. Every number in it is made up to show the math. Angi doesn’t publish lead prices, and yours will differ by trade and area.
| Hypothetical | Pay per lead, normal month | Pay per lead, slow month | Subscription, normal month | Subscription, slow month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price per lead (hypothetical) | $60 | $60 | $50 (prepaid discount) | $100 in effect (same prepay, half the leads) |
| Leads delivered (hypothetical) | 20 | 10 | 20 | 10 |
| What you pay (hypothetical) | $1,200 | $600 | $1,000 | $1,000 |
| Share you win (hypothetical) | 25% | 20% | 25% | 20% |
| Booked jobs | 5 | 2 | 5 | 2 |
| Cost per booked job | $240 | $300 | $200 | $500 |
In a good month the subscription discount wins. In a slow month the same commitment more than doubles what each booked job costs, because the prepaid amount doesn’t shrink when requests dry up. On pay per lead the slow month costs less in total, and you can request credits for invalid leads.
The share you win moves the result more than the price does. Each request goes to up to five pros, so in our experience a business that answers in minutes and quotes clearly books far more of the same leads than one that calls back the next day. Angi says letting homeowners choose their pros raised pros’ self-reported win rate by more than 60% (Angi Q4 2024 shareholder letter, 2025). That’s Angi’s own figure, so track your own.
To run this for your business, divide what you paid Angi last month by the jobs you booked from it. If you can’t say how many jobs that was, start there. Our guide to sizing a home service marketing budget from booked jobs works the same math for every channel.
Which business each option suits
Pay per lead suits a new or one-truck business with open slots on the calendar. You can start with a small monthly budget, pause for two weeks when you’re booked out and stop when your own marketing brings in enough work.
The subscription suits a business that has run pay per lead for a while, knows its win rate on Angi requests and sees steady volume in its area. Only then is the discount worth the term, the possible early termination fee and the loss of lead credits.
Established multi-crew companies are a different case. In our experience, once a company is running several crews and routes, shared requests become a small and expensive slice of the work. The homeowners who search for the company by name, or find it in Google’s map results, tend to book at better margins and stay longer. For those companies the question is usually how fast they can replace Angi spend with demand they own.
Owning your own demand instead
Every homeowner who reaches you through your own website, Google Business Profile or ads is a request you don’t share with up to four other pros. You pay for the click or the SEO work once, and the customer’s next call comes straight to you.
It takes longer to build than switching on an Angi budget. In our experience, many owners run both while their own channels catch up, then cut Angi as booked jobs from search grow. We lay out that path in the section on owning your own demand, and it’s the work behind our local SEO for home service companies and Google and Meta ads management for home service companies, with a page for each of the home service trades we work with. If you go that way, set up tracking for booked jobs from Google Ads so you can compare cost per booked job against what Angi charged you.
Questions owners ask
Is HomeAdvisor still a thing?
Yes, as a brand homeowners use. Angi Inc. still runs HomeAdvisor alongside Angi, Angie’s List and Handy (Angi Inc. 2025 annual report). For pros, HomeAdvisor Pro is now Angi Leads, so you sign up and pay through Angi.
Is Angi Leads worth it?
It depends on what each booked job costs you. Each request goes to up to five pros, and you pay for the lead whether or not you win it (Angi Pro Agreement, checked November 11, 2026). If you answer fast and book a good share of those requests, pay per lead can fill a calendar. If you can’t tie Angi spend to booked jobs, find that out before you sign a subscription.
Is Thumbtack better than HomeAdvisor?
Thumbtack gives you more control over price. You set your own lead prices (“the exact amount you’ll pay”) on a weekly budget. It also offers preset jobs where it keeps a percentage of the job price instead of charging up front (Thumbtack help center, checked November 11, 2026). Which one books more jobs depends on your trade and area, so test both with small budgets and compare cost per booked job.
What happened to Angi Ads?
Angi stopped selling it in March 2025 and retired it in the fourth quarter of 2025 (Angi Inc. 2025 annual report). Pros who had Angi Ads contracts were moved to a subscription for leads. You can no longer buy it.
Sources: HomeAdvisor pro site, checked November 11, 2026, https://pro.homeadvisor.com/. Angi Inc. press release on the Angi name change, March 17, 2021, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1705110/000170511021000033/angi_prfinal.htm. Angi Inc. Form 10-K for 2021, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1705110/000170511022000021/angi-20211231.htm. Angi Inc. Form 10-K for 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1705110/000170511026000011/angi-20251231.htm. Angi Q1 2025 earnings release, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1705110/000170511025000041/q12025earningsrelease.htm. Angi Q4 2024 shareholder letter, February 11, 2025, https://ir.angi.com/static-files/30e7abc1-83bc-487c-bdc5-ded45c4de0d8. Angi help center, checked November 11, 2026: opportunities and leads FAQ, billing FAQ, monthly budgets, pausing leads, lead credits and lead statuses. Angi Pro Agreement, last updated October 6, 2026, checked November 11, 2026, https://angiads.pactsafe.io/versions/6ac568925ab7ef3fa4859c92.pdf. FTC final order against HomeAdvisor, April 2023, FTC press release. Thumbtack help center, checked November 11, 2026: types of leads, setting lead prices and setting a budget.